The List is extremely lax in terms of super hero movies. The addition of Black Panther in the latest edition makes for the third superhero movie included, which is surprising. Of all of the superhero movies that have existed, Logan is in many ways the most serious and the most contemplative, and because of it, the one that in many ways has the most to say. It’s also the sort of superhero movie that is worth watching even by those who don’t normally cotton to the genre. It’s one of those rare films that transcends the genre it’s in, and it should be recognized.
2. Wonder Woman (2017)
We’re staying in the same genre with Wonder Woman, and we’re even staying in the same year. The reason for its inclusion, though, is completely different. If we’re going to talk about importance, it’s impossible not to include Wonder Woman in the discussion. For a major action release—based on a superhero, no less—to feature a woman as the main character and to be this good and this effective as well as this successful should be a wake-up call for the industry. We’ve yet to see if it is (Captain Marvel may well cement this truth), but it’s certainly something that should make everyone sit up and take notice.
Film has had a long-standing relationship with the world of sports, and few films deal with that relationship more aggressively than This Sporting Life. That may, in fact, be why this film hasn’t been named to the list. Rather than glamorizing the sporting world, this film instead shows it to be dirty and seamy, ugly and brutal. It is perhaps the most surprising and robust performance in the career of Richard Harris, who gives a masterclass in playing a brute. It’s an impressive film in every way it can possibly be impressive.
4. Gone Girl (2014)
The thriller genre always wants us to think one thing while presenting a film that ends up somewhere completely different. We’re being faked out, and a large part of the thrill is understanding that there’s going to be an attempt to make us doubt everything we’ve seen. Gone Girl does this better than just about anything from the last decade or so. It’s another reminder that Ben Affleck belongs behind the camera rather than in front of it. And holy shit, that reveal! Few movies have done it better.
I’m still shocked that Hotel Rwanda isn’t here, since it seems like exactly the sort of movie that dominates the 1001 Movies List. This is a social injustice film, a genocide film, a political film, and a triumph of the human spirit film all wrapped up in one package. It’s the sort of film that people watch once and never again. That’s almost certainly going to be my relationship with it, but I’m glad that I saw it. Of all of the movies I have suggested be added to The List, this is the one I’m the most interested in learning why it’s never made it on.
6. Grand Hotel (1932)
Grand Hotel holds the unique distinction of being the only Best Picture winner that was not nominated for another Oscar. It also catches a lot of hell from people into films of this vintage and I’ve never understood why. There’s so much to like about Grand Hotel in the way the narrative works. In a better world than the one we live in, this would have continued for a second movie that starts where this one ends, and they would have continued on and on, with stories starting and ending and intertwining for years and years.
7. Went the Day Well? (1942)
Propaganda films are their own little corner of the cinematic swimming pool, and those that are created while the war is going on are particularly fascinating to me. Went the Day Well? posits a German invasion of a small British village by German paratroopers and, naturally the fierce and ultimately vicious retaliation of the villagers. The story doesn’t avoid the idea of a fifth column and isn’t shy with the killing of otherwise innocent people whose only crime is fighting back against oppression. It’s a hell of a movie for what it is.
8. The Dead Zone (1983)
Adaptations of Stephen King stories come in essentially four varieties. There are those that are very good but are not really horror stories (The Green Mile, The Shawshank Redemption, Stand By Me). There are the movies that are awful adaptations (Maximum Overdrive) and there are the good horror adaptations that are wildly different from the original text. The Dead Zone falls somewhere between the first and third categories. Not really a horror film, but with clear horror elements, this is a film that demonstrates that it’s possible to be faithful to King’s stories.
9. Sophie’s Choice (1982)
I could probably create a list of ten movies that are Holocaust-based or connected that aren’t on The List that could or should be, and that’s coming from the position where I think The List is already too Holocaust-heavy. Sophie’s Choice seems like such a natural choice for The List, though. It contains one of the truly great performances from perhaps the greatest actor in film history and has that dark dramatic theme that the listmakers seem to love. Sophie’s Choice is actually noteworthy in its absence, and I’m continually surprised that it’s not here.
10. Watership Down (1978)
The List has always been light on animated films and, along with horror and science fiction, the biggest knock against it is its constant decision to leave off these somehow less important genres and styles. Watership Down is an early entrant in the category of animated films that are clearly not made for children, a film that really could not have been made any other way with a chance at remaining faithful to the source material. It’s also a film that I’m staggered by the fact that it exists at all. Of course, I could say the same thing about the book itself.
Some very good choices here. I would certainly include Watership Down, The Dead Zone and Grand Hotel. I'm a bit surprised Hotel Rwanda was never in any edition of the book, either. You see what a small number 1,001 is in this context when you have to take some movies out to add others. I guess we could probably lose Vinyl and Blonde Cobra.ReplyDelete
I'd agree with dropping Blonde Cobra. For as much as I hate Vinyl (I maintain that it is the worst movie I have ever seen), I understand its inclusion.Delete
But yeah, there's still a lot of chaff.
This Sporting Life and Grand Hotel are on my watchlist and your post has encouraged me to bump them up the queue! Sophie’s Choice is a great choice,still impactful even though I've rewatched a few times.ReplyDelete
I hope they live up to at least some of the hype. This Sporting Life is particularly good.Delete
This is a fun exercise and while none of these are on my List, mostly because I have seen only one of them, I can definitely see that there is still a lot to watch. This Sporting Life was definitely a miss when I went through that year. If you have any suggestions for 1967 I am all ears.ReplyDelete
The Dirty Dozen springs to mind. The Whisperers is interesting and disturbing, if you can find it. Seriously, though, 1967 is a pretty packed year if memory serves.Delete
I decided to watch the 1913 version of Quo Vadis? this morning. This is relevant to the discussion because I have long thought that the early Italian cinema should be represented on the List. Before Birth of a Nation, filmmakers in Italy produced a bunch of feature films, some of which are very impressive. It has always surprised me that the List has ignored very early Italian cinema despite finding room for films like Gertrud and Louisiana Story.ReplyDelete
I am not an expert on these early films, so I'm not really sure which Italian film from 1911 to 1915 is the best choice, but of the few I've seen, I would suggest either Dante's Inferno (1911) or Cabiria (1914).
And I heartily endorse Grand Hotel! I've seen it a few times over the years.Delete
There almost certainly are some early ones that I should watch and that are worth adding. The List is really lax on some of the great early comedians, and still has only one Valentino film (and not the right one).ReplyDelete