Monday, September 16, 2013

Love at Arm's Length

Film: Le Conseguenze dell’Amore (The Consequences of Love)
Format: Internet video on laptop.

Before I get into this, I need to once again thank Chip Lary over at Tips from Chip. He not only located this film streaming online, he also walked me through the process of getting it to stream. (Note to Chip: The process worked the same way in Chrome). Chip has rapidly become the patron saint of 1001 Movies bloggers as well as our bodhisattva.

Films like Le Conseguenze dell’Amore (The Consequences of Love) are the reason The List exists in the first place. I mean that positively. This is not a film that I would have picked up on my own, but now, having seen it, I’m happy to evangelize on its behalf. Underseen films like this one, films of particular beauty and power are the reason listmakers make their lists. It’s to get people like me to see something we should, something that will move us or get us to think or show us something that will change us. Le Conseguenze dell’Amore has the potential to be that sort of a film.

We start very slow and become immersed in the sedate life of Titta di Girolamo (Toni Servillo), a man who lives on his own in a posh hotel in Switzerland. We know very little about him for some time. He likes to sit in the bar of his hotel. He walks alone through the streets of his city. He suffers from insomnia. He also avoids almost all physical and indeed human contact.

Over time, we learn a bit more about him. He has an unusual drug habit, for one thing. He is extremely punctual in all things. He sometimes takes delivery of a large suitcase full of money and deposits it in a nearby bank. This happens about once a week. We don’t learn until the film is about 2/3 done where the money comes from or why Titta lives the way he does. We don’t know why he has evidently divorced or separated from his wife and has no real contact with his children. All we really know for the bulk of the running time is that he lives the way he does for a reason, and part of that either requires a lack of human contact or that the lack of human contact is a part of who Titta is.

I’d rather not get into too many details here. It is sufficient to say and not much of a shock to suggest that the suitcase full of money comes from non-legitimate means and that the money isn’t his. When a couple of gun-toting men show up and spend some time in Titta’s room, that conclusion becomes even easier to draw, although we don’t learn the truth until well after this happens.

The event that motivates the actions in Le Conseguenze dell’Amore is the presence of the barmaid in the hotel where Titta lives. Sofia (Olivia Magnani) greets and says goodbye to Titta every day she works and he never responds to her. It’s evident by the way he looks at her that he is attracted to her despite their vast difference in ages. When she confronts him over his apparent rudeness, it begins a very tentative romance. The romance between Titta and Sofia is definitely there despite there being nothing physical between them. It’s almost as if Titta wants to take care of her as a surrogate for the children with whom he has lost contact.

Things change again not when Titta figures out a way to skim money off the top of his bank transactions, but when the two men with guns return and walk away with a week’s shipment. But since this happens around Titta’s 50th birthday and he has made plans with Sofia, he must make a series of choices that will determine his fate, these choices being the consequences of love mentioned in the film’s title.

One of the many things I like about Le Conseguenze dell’Amore is that it gives us the character of Titta to spend time with. I love characters who are truly unique but not in a specifically comic way. Titta isn’t wacky or silly or at all frivolous (a comment he makes early on). He is rather a character unlike any other I have encountered. He is entirely self-contained and acts on his own ideas in full knowledge of but without regard to the consequences. He is singularly fascinating.

I’d love to say more about this film, but I don’t want to because it’s one that people should discover on their own. It’s that sort of experience. It is strangely beautiful, and the slow pace at the beginning especially is never boring, but comes across as, for lack of a better word, lush. It feels bigger than it is, more special and more absorbing than it should be.

I haven’t been overwhelmed by the latest additions from the 10th Edition, but this one is a win all the way through.

Why to watch Le Conseguenze dell’Amore: A strange and strangely beautiful love story.
Why not to watch: The ending is something you won’t like, even though it’s great.


  1. I haven't seen this yet, but I wanted to comment on the first paragraph.

    "Chip has rapidly become the patron saint of 1001 Movies bloggers"

    "St. Chip"? I'm getting visions of the movie King Ralph. :-)

    "as well as our bodhisattva"

    If you'll excuse me, I have to go think some Deep Thoughts. :-)

    Seriously, though, thanks man for the very kind words. I'll return to this post when I have seen the movie (hopefully today or tomorrow.)

    1. True is true, my friend. "Bodhisattva" is the perfect title for you. Certainly better than Pope Chip.

  2. Well, after you went and said such nice things about me I feel really bad saying that this film didn't have the effect on me that it did on you.

    I didn't have a problem with the ending. Like you said, you can pretty much see where it is going. And even before starting it you know a film named The Consequences of Love is not going to be a happily ever after kind of movie.

    I didn't have anything in the film I particularly disliked, though. I did feel a certain accident was kind of silly the way it was set up, but that is a minor complaint. There were some interesting camera shots in the film.

    I just wasn't as fascinated by it, for whatever reason. Sorry.

    1. Not every film works for everyone. I agree with you about the car accident, incidentally, except that it's another consequence of love, based on how she got the car.

  3. I watched this a couple of nights ago but I don't have a lot to say about it. I liked it well enough, and I agree with you that Titta is quite an interesting (and unique) character. And I thought Olivia Mangani was very good in her role as Sofia.

    I got a little confused at the end. I was watching it in the morning and I don't think I was fully engaged and probably missed some important dialogue (which happens with me sometimes when I watch movies with sub-titles). Was there anything that I missed about the bodies in Sofia's car? Didn't Titta kill those guys and put them in the trunk? Was it a different car? Or is Sofia going to face a lot of unpleasant questions about two murders if she ever comes out of the coma?

    For Sofia, the consequences of love may go way beyond being an inexperienced driver going too fast in bad weather and being too trusting of mannequins dressed as traffic police.

    1. I;d have to rewatch to know about the bodies, honestly. It's been some time.