Format: DVD from DeKalb Public Library on kick-ass portable DVD player.
We all have those movies upon which we disagree with everyone else. I’m not talking about disliking a film like Citizen Kane; it’s become chic to hate on Welles’s classic with a certain type of film fan and/or blogger. No, I mean everyone has a couple of “everyone likes it” films that fit in a couple of other slots. First, there’s the “everyone likes it but me” film for those that gets universal praise…except for you. That’s Forrest Gump for me, and a few others I can think of. Then there are those films that just seem to wash over without leaving a solid impression. It’s not bad, per se, but you just can’t understand why everyone else loves it so much. In that category for me, first and foremost, is The French Connection.
It’s not a stretch to say that this is a widely loved and lauded film. It won a bunch of Oscars, including some of the biggies like Best Picture, Actor, Adapted Screenplay, and Director. I remember being excited the first time I saw it. And then…well… I shrug my shoulders. I simply don’t get it. I understand that it’s a good movie. I get that the action was innovative for the time. I understand that Gene Hackman was on top of his game. I just don’t understand why people seem to lose their shit over what seems to be a pretty standard cop drama. I feel alone in this, like I’m not in on the joke. This is a film that has been preserved as culturally important, one that’s still discussed. I don’t see anything here that’s so special, though. At least, what I see here I also saw in Bullitt from three or four years previous.
So I’m going to discuss this as best I can, but please feel free to comment and explain to me exactly what is so damn significant about The French Connection. Please help me to understand the cultural importance of this film, because I really don’t get it.
James “Popeye” Doyle (Gene Hackman) is a cop on the narcotics beat. He and his partner Buddy “Cloudy” Russo (Roy Scheider) make a quick bust and get the name of the junkie’s connection. This leads them into the drug smuggling underworld in which the majority of the heroin in the Americas is coming in through New York via France. This connection, a man named Charnier (Fernando Rey) uses a variety of methods to bring in the smack, the most interesting being inside the rocker panels of imported cars. We discover a lack of hard drugs on the streets, which means that the next shipment will have an entire city filled with eager, strung-out buyers.
Doyle and Russo are onto this, though, and start tailing Charnier, who soon realizes that he’s being followed. His second, a man named Nicoli (Marcel Bozzuffi), offers to bump off Doyle, which eventually leads to one of the stand-out scenes. Nicoli hijacks an elevated train, and Doyle commandeers a car, chasing the train through city streets. Eventually, the train is forced to stop and Doyle guns down Nicoli on the stairs up to the train platform.
There’s also some involvement from the Feds, who appear to function more or less as a way to keep tabs on Doyle and Russo. Eventually, the cops find the drugs but allow them to go back to the criminals so that they can bust everyone during the buy, and then all hell breaks loose and the film ends essentially while the firefight is still sort of going on.
I understand a few things here beyond this being a fairly straightforward (at least today) cop drama. Doyle’s character is the interesting one, and he’s interesting in a lot of ways because he’s a good cop who isn’t completely clean. He’s a racist, he’s violent, he’s angry, but he’s also a cop who gets bad guys off the street and is trying to do the job that he’s been paid to do. I get that. I also get just how groundbreaking the chase scene is, although as mentioned above, there are shades of Bullitt in this.
In other words, I see why The French Connection is a good film. What I don’t see is why it’s a great film. I’d be more than willing to watch it again using the good advice of someone else because I just don’t see it. In fact, I’ve talked to a number of people about this and have never really gotten a straight answer. More and more, it seems like people accept this as a great film because everyone else does. I’d like to understand why. If you know, please tell me.
Why to watch The French Connection: Cops who aren’t clean or dirty, but real.
Why not to watch: For a film that’s so important, it doesn’t seem very important.
I'm with you on this one. I didn't care for this one at all. And the big chase scene was just... so boring. I don't even see the big deal with that one, honestly.ReplyDelete
Well, based on when it was filmed, it was a pretty exciting chase. There hadn't really been a lot of good high-speed chase scenes that didn't involve speeding up the film before that.Delete
But, yeah. Glad I'm not the only one.
I really like this film, but I can see why others might not. The chase is probably my favourite in movie history, and managed to hold my attention though I'm not a big car guy, and the scene on the subway platform, stepping on and off the train, is brilliant. I can't really say why it's gone down in movie history (it is vastly superior to Bullitt though) but I think it could be due to showing all the painstaking hours of policework required to work on a case - all the wire tapping and car dismantling. It always annoyed me that the bigger breakthroughs seemed to be down to luck though.ReplyDelete
I thought it was a good movie, but not one of the best. I'm with you in that. I think part of what makes a movie great is when it's discovered or first seen by lots of people. In this case, when it came out. It must have made a huge impression for some reason that's lost on us later. A good example of my theory is the AFI list. The first time the list came out The Graduate was #7. I hate that movie, and I told people that as time went by and the Boomers weren't the voting majority it would drop. 10 years later when they did the list again The Graduate was at #17, dropping a whole 10 spots. The French Connection is probably somewhat like that.ReplyDelete
Steve, in a weird way, I agree and disagree with you. I don't consider it an "important" film, especially since there were other great cop films in the '70s. I do consider it a very good police movie that's beefed up by several excellent sequences. There's the obvious car chase that works for me because it feels raw and risky to shoot. I also like the earlier scene with them following the French guy on foot and then getting burned. It's built a reputation as a groundbreaking movie, when it's really just a damn good movie. Not a personal favorite, but a well-acted and interesting film.ReplyDelete
Thanks for all of the comments, folks. I guess this is going to remain a movie that I don't understand the greatness of. I think Retro might be right on it.ReplyDelete
I saw both this and the sequel quite a few years ago, and even though I have a pretty good memory for movies, I remember almost nothing about either of them. This is usually a sign of a film that just didn't make that big an impression on me. I remember liking the chase scene. I didn't dislike the movie, but I didn't think it was all that, either.ReplyDelete
Perhaps it's a generational thing as suggested above. I know a bunch of people 15-20 years older than I am who think this film is all that and a bag of chips.Delete
I can't help you much on the film itself -- I saw it many years ago, but I suspect your "Why to Watch It" played a big part in its appeal -- but I can direct you to this piece by The AV Club discussing the chase scene... Which, apparently, was less of a "stunt" and more of a "f' it, we'll do it live!" kind of thing.ReplyDelete
The thing is, Bullitt did the same damn thing. McQueen actually drove the car 90+ on city streets.Delete
This is EXACTLY how I felt watching it. Instead of the great film I expected I was actually bored much of the time. This may have been innovative in its day, but how many times have we watched this exact story in endless tv series?ReplyDelete
I still say Bullitt did it first and did it better. But what do I know?Delete